Mar 20, 2008

Where do you get your ideas?

For a long time I would laugh whenever I heard a writer complain of a reader asking this question. I stopped laughing the day it happened to me. I was on holiday in Tuscany in a hotel largely taken over by British visitors. I avoided the conversations involving work and questions of what everyone did for a living as long as I could. After all, when on holiday why talk about work? I also strongly feel that a person isn’t necessarily shaped by what they do for a living. If a person is lucky enough to make their hobby their career, then perhaps there’s some truth to be found in how a person earns their income. However, many people work in jobs they detest. They do what they need to do to pay the bills, and have to regulate what they love to do to hours outside of the office. This applies to most writers, but that’s another subject.

So, when a woman asked me what I ‘do’, sheer devilment took hold of me and I said “I’m a writer.” This is the truth and it’s closer to who I am than anything I’ve had to do keep a roof over my head or put food on the table. Her eyes positively lit up.

“I’ve never met a writer before,” she said. “Where DO you get your ideas?”

And right there I found myself speechless. Totally unprepared, I had no idea how to answer her. In truth, there is no definitive answer to this question. The truth is that ideas come from anywhere and everywhere. You will get an idea from something someone said, something you read, or something you saw. You might file an event away and it won’t be until days, weeks, months, sometimes years later, when something else occurs, and then your mind makes a connection so that suddenly you have a story.

I don’t know if everyone has this ability to make seemingly random connections or if writers are simply people who are aware of this skill and choose to use it. In any case, writers appear to see the world a little differently. People often accuse writers of living in a fantasy world, and yet many writers appear to see the world as a stark reality. Writers see all the good and bad in the world for without conflict there is no story. They are always cataloging information in their minds or on paper to use at some undefined time. Writers also play the ‘What If’ game.

Perhaps the easiest way is to show by example. Take my m/m contemporary book “Snow Angel.” Check out this page at Loose-Id to read the prologue that the publisher chose as an excerpt. The prologue was primarily the whole basis of my story. I saw someone walking along a road and mistaking a person’s identity. I thought ‘what if’ I created a brother and sister with similar features and this guy grabbed the wrong person?

With “Uly’s Comet”, which was the start of my Swithin Chronicles trilogy -- the third book scheduled for the beginning of April -- I simply saw a man sitting on a bench in open parkland and a thief about to creep up on him. I had no idea as to the identity of these characters, or the thief’s sex, let alone their sexuality. Then a few weeks later, I was looking through a baby-naming book in search of a name for another completely unrelated project, and I came across a word: Shavar (meaning Comet). At once, I knew the identity of the man sitting on the bench as well as why he sat there. I then asked myself questions as to what could be different about his race. I created the Swithin who freely take lovers of either sex. That idea filled in the missing pieces. I would set a few rules that the Swithin prince had to live by then lay temptation in his path. One reader remarked that the comet books are a cross between Prince and the Pauper meets Arabian Nights. The comparison hadn’t occurred to me until someone brought it to my attention, but it makes me smile and laugh.

There’s a school of thought that you can write a story from someone just giving you a few unrelated words. Maybe even a single word. The flash fiction pieces the Loose-Id authors write here proves the theory. You can also write from a title only. My very first published short story came from a five-word title.

So, the simple answer to where writers get their ideas from is anywhere and everywhere. However, there’s nothing simple about it. There’s a reason they call life stranger than fiction. Ideas bombard us every day. A writer is someone with the ability to see where worlds collide and people or events connect in new, interesting, and unpredictable ways. Happy Reading!

Sharon Maria Bidwell
aonia - where the muses live
http://www.sharonbidwell.co.uk
http://www.myspace.com/aonia

10 comments:

Rue said...

Awesome, Sharon! I love "Snow Angel" and "Angel Heart", so it was really cool to learn how it all started.

Anne Brooke said...

Very interesting, Sharon - and so true!

:))

A
xxx

Jeanne said...

My dh says I have a weird mind. *g*
Great post, Sharon.
I agree. I get my ideas from just about everywhere. Music, in particular, primes my pump. And it needn't be a vocal piece.
Simpliest answer then: we get our ideas from everything and everywhere

Jules Jones said...

There's a related thing - "I've got a brilliant idea for a story. Why don't you write it up for me, and I'll give you half the money."

I know enough writers who've had this experience on a regular basis that there are obviously a lot of people out there who think that story ideas are rare and precious things. But the reality is that if you're a writer, it's more a problem of fending the things off. "Go away, I'm writing *this* story now, you'll have to wait."

S.M.Bidwell said...

Thanks for dropping by and reading. Nothing wrong with a weird mind, Jeanne. :o)

LOL. Oh Jules, that's priceless. No, can't say I've ever been asked to write something up for someone, though I have been approached by people wanting to write with me. I'm not saying I'll never do this but it would probably have to be someone I know in some other way first and I'd want to check out their work, published or not.

I do sometimes have to work on developing an idea but if they came any faster I wouldn't know how to cope. I've loads of ideas lined up and not enough time, which no doubt sounds all too familiar to many writers. Want to know how precious time is just ask a writer.

GrowlyCub said...

I can understand why that question can be a bit of an annoyance. In defense of us readers, I have to say, however, that I'm endlessly fascinated by how these stories come about, because I do not have people talking in my head and I kinda wish I did.

It takes too long for my favorite authors to write enough of the stories I love. :)

Jules Jones said...

Oh, I'll blather on at length about the origins of my stories, given half the chance. :-) (Maybe I should do a blog post about a couple of them.) And I understand the "where do you get your ideas?" question, because I had pretty much no interest in writing fiction for about fifteen years, and then discovered fanfiction and something I wanted to write about. But I do hear some weird twists from my friends about variations they've heard on that theme. There's a reason why writers joke about signing up to a subscription service that delivers a fresh lot of story ideas every month.

And in fact, in a metaphorical sense, that's essentially what many of us do, at least some of the time. I have a "story idea" tag in my email client and on my LiveJournal. And when I read something that sets off an interesting train of thought, I tag it so that I can find it later. Most of them never get used, but they're there, waiting...

Mya said...

I have a case of too many ideas and wish greatly that I could type faster than I do...a measly 50wpm.

I get a lot of ideas from monster movies (Mortal Kombat/Project Metal Beast) and cuisine though. One story (werecat) was inspired by Fancy Feast Shredded Fare...my cat luvs shredded salmon with fresh greens...

Sassy Brit @ Alternative-Read.com said...

Great post Shaz! It is a hard one to explain.

Ideas come from your imagination, and anything can cause the imagination to run riot!

Sometimes it almost feels as though I am channelling what I write through some sort of guide, who has all the answers. Like, where the hell did that come from?

Either way, we always start off with the same -- a blank piece of paper...

Sassy
Alternative-Read.com
XXX

Theolyn Boese said...

Well, I've said it before but... The TC books started as a dare and basically I was writing about my pet peeves from many romance and sci-fi/fantasy novels I've read over the years.

But, I have to agree that we get ideas from everything we see and hear. I outlined an entire plot based on 1 second of film I saw in a movie preview. Sometimes one little thing will just click and then the whole story cascades from it.

As for the "I have a great I idea , you should write it..." That's happened to me, too. And, honestly? I really don't want to write about Great Grandma's Great Trek across the plains in a covered wagon. Now, if Great Grandma liked kinky sex, maybe with flexible aliens from Planet X.... Ew, naw, too much info.


~Theolyn

Design by: Anne Douglas based on Arsenal by FinalSense